Using Data for Better Nonprofit Program Management
By: Brent Chism, CEO, TaroWorks
“Data can be used as either a rear-view mirror or as headlights. Successful organizations are using it as a headlight,” observed my colleague Elaine Chang during a recent webinar about using Salesforce.org Nonprofit Cloud platform for continuous improvement.
At TaroWorks, a Salesforce.org partner, we find that a growing number of nonprofits and social enterprises want to use data to spotlight future nonprofit program management opportunities and challenges, in addition to evaluating what’s already happened. The problem is: nonprofit program managers either lack the knowledge or the tools to expand their focus.
They’re not alone. The Salesforce.org 2018 Nonprofit Trends Report polled more than 450 nonprofit leaders, 53% of whom found it easy to collect program data. The challenge was putting the information to use as fewer than half (47%) of the respondents said it was easy to analyze that same data and only 39% said they had identified and tracked the correct performance metrics. Nonprofits may not know how to take advantage of the latest innovations like artificial intelligence, while the amount of data in the world (and in your programs) is increasing every year.
Intelligent Mission Delivery: Data for “Headlights” and Not a “Rear-View Mirror”
TaroWorks helps organizations with field agents use Salesforce to extend their work into some of the most challenging areas of the globe. We support social enterprises and nonprofits in more than 40 countries in the Global South – where infrastructure like wifi, electricity and running water are not guaranteed to be available 24/7, if at all. Additionally, social changemakers we serve operate in areas with staff who in many cases lack the digital literacy to use traditional Salesforce tools. They also face all the normal challenges that can kill any IT project, like budget constraints, data silos, and no advocate to champion the cause.
TaroWorks in use in Northern Kenya by a field agent from The Boma Project. Source: TaroWorks
Despite the challenges, however, some of our clients use data in sophisticated ways. So how did they evolve from looking in the data rear-view mirror to a shining a data headlight on the road to intelligent mission delivery?
To Improve Your Data Management, Keep it Simple!
Several decades ago, John Gall postulated a law of systems stating that “A complex system that works is invariably found to have evolved from a simple system that worked.”
In fact, organizations make more sophisticated use of data over time. Research and advisory firm Gartner, Inc. illustrates this evolution in a four-stage framework (included in its October 5, 2018 “2019 Planning Guide for Data and Analytics”) which we think is applicable to nonprofit and for-profit enterprises. Data analysis capabilities begin as descriptive (What happened?) and diagnostic (Why did it happen?) but progress to predictive (What will happen?) and prescriptive (What should I do?).
We also think Gartner points to an imbalance in the way data at all four analytics capability levels is analyzed and distributed through organizations.
“Although Gartner estimates that a vast majority of organizations’ analytics efforts (and budgets) are spent on descriptive and diagnostic analytics, a significant part of that work is now handled by business users doing their own analysis,” according to the Gartner planning guide. “This work often occurs outside the realm of the sanctioned IT data and analytics architecture. Predictive and prescriptive capabilities, on the other hand, are usually focused within individual business units and are not widely leveraged across the organization. That mix must change.”
When TaroWorks first meets most organizations, they are in the descriptive and diagnostic stage of data analysis. Often, they start their evolution by deploying the Salesforce.org Nonprofit Cloud and then adding TaroWorks mobile field service app from the AppExchange.
Here is one client that used powerful analytics tools from TaroWorks and Salesforce.org to analyze data in a less descriptive and more prescriptive way.
From Descriptive to Prescriptive: Should We Hand Out Cash…Or Toilet Paper?
Sustainable Organic Integrated Livelihoods (SOIL) is a nonprofit research and development organization designing and implementing a social business model for providing access to a safe, affordable and dignified sanitation service that produces rich, organic compost as a natural resource for Haiti’s badly-depleted soils as well as economic opportunities for its citizens.
For a small monthly fee, SOIL supplies in-home container-based toilets to 1,000 Haitian households and services them on a weekly basis. In 2018, it safely treated and transformed nearly 500 tons of waste into compost that is used to support agriculture and reforestation efforts throughout the country.
SOIL team handling containers. Source: Tony Marcelli for SOIL
Challenge. SOIL’s field agents first used pen and paper to log sales, toilet installations, weekly servicing and other business activities and then transcribed the information into spreadsheets. As their customer base grew, it became clear their ability to scale operations, link distributed data and make business decisions in real-time was limited by their lack of an integrated, flexible and mobile data management system. Lastly, SOIL needed its mobile field services tool to function in areas where mobile phone data service and internet connections were limited or unreliable and field agents speak Haitian Creole.
Solution. SOIL uses TaroWorks’ offline mobile CRM capability to provide company payment collectors access to a customer’s payment history and to conduct market research surveys. Salesforce data visualization dashboards give SOIL’s managers powerful business insights into the most effective sales and marketing techniques. Read more from TaroWorks.
These Salesforce reports and dashboards helped SOIL gain new insights about their sales and marketing tactics. For example, SOIL conducted customer research on which offers drive the most toilet sales. In one experiment, SOIL customers in some areas preferred receiving bonuses for referring new customers — in toilet paper rather than cash. SOIL used that insight to identify similar neighborhoods and uses hygiene products as incentives in those areas. SOIL data analysts also discovered that their customer responded more to time-limited discounts, like special weekend sales offers, than monthly promotions. Read more from TaroWorks.
Data Culture Eats IT Strategy
Management guru Peter Drucker reportedly observed, “Culture eats strategy for breakfast,” meaning that an organization’s culture is crucial for data strategy evolution.
That has been the case at organizations I have seen make the shift from data rear-view mirror to data headlights. Kathleen Kelly Janus, a lecturer at the Stanford Program on Social Entrepreneurship, studied many more social entrepreneurs and reached a similar conclusion.
“Creating a data culture is critical to their success…. In my survey of 250 social entrepreneurs, organizations that began measuring their impact from the start tended to have a faster path to scale.” It’s true that “some of the most important practices of successful startups can’t be measured,” Janu notes. “But figuring out what we can measure and measuring it effectively is essential to the success of organizations that want to achieve impact.”
For more resources on intelligent mission delivery and how to get started from data to AI for nonprofits, see:
- The Nonprofit AI Digital Magazine
- Broadcast: Social good in an AI-powered world
- Webinar: Intro to AI for Nonprofits
- Master Class: Best Practices for Smarter Impact with AI
- Nonprofits Using Artificial Intelligence
About the Author
Brent Chism is CEO of TaroWorks, a social enterprise launched by Grameen Foundation to sell a mobile offline field service management app that helps data, project and program managers collect and analyze metrics in the field, oversee sales teams, manage construction projects, direct supply chains, and increase field agent productivity in emerging markets.
TaroWorks is an official Salesforce.org AppExchange Partner. Find their app on the AppExchange.
You Might Also Like
Read about the Grassroots Mobile Survey — an open-source, accessible solution that enables workers and volunteers to collect data wherever…
An Interview with Lindsay Gruber on building corporate resilience through pro bono volunteerism.
Each year, as we observe the International Day for the Abolition of Slavery on December 2, we have an opportunity…